Books

The Science of Homeopathy – page 123

confusion and controversy which have resulted since Hahnemann’s death have caused tremendous degrees of misunderstanding about the miasmatic concept; for this reason, in this book I will emphasize the term predisposition rather than “miasm.” In addition, I will not de- scribe the detailed clinical signs and symptoms associated with each miasm, in order to keep readers from being misled into the idea of prescribing specifically on the basis of the miasm alone.

A further confusion which has arisen since Hahnemann’s time is that certain miasms are a complex combination of two or more of the original three miasms. The best-known example of confusion over this issue is that the so-called Tuberculosis Miasm is actually a combina- tion of Psora and Syphilis. The known history of diseases on the planet clearly contradicts this theory. Tuberculosis is one of the earliest dis- eases known to mankind, found in skeletons of the earliest primitive humans. Syphilis, on the other hand, was unknown to the European continent until brought from North America by Columbus.3

The most important contribution of Hahnemann’s explorations into the miasms is the concept that there exist layers of predisposition which underlie the waxing and waning of temporary ailments; these must be taken into account in treatment intending to be completely curative. In such cases, complete cure will take a relatively long time, while the prescriber systematically peels off layer upon layer of predis- posing weaknesses by carefully prescribing each remedy based on the totality of symptoms in the moment (see Figure 9). Each layer is always the result of the underlying ones, and there is a definite sequence to the presenting layers. If a remedy is prescribed routinely, based merely on the past or family history and not on the presenting symptomatology of the patient, the remedy may actually disrupt any progress toward cure. Even worse, such a prescription may disorder the defense mechanism enough to make the image of the correct remedy much more difficult to discern.



The concept of predisposing layers had considerable practical value in chronic relapsing cases. For example, if a patient consults a homeo- path for chronic headaches that began after exposure to cold, and the prescriber gives belladonna, he may find that the headaches disappear dramatically. If the patient has a quite strong constitution to begin with, the problem may remain cured for a long time. However, the vast majority of patients have been weakened through hereditary influence, drugs, or vaccinations, resulting in several layers of predisposition. At the time when the above patient first consults the homeopath, the total- ity of symptoms at that moment represents only the uppermost layer

3. Folke Henschen, The History of Diseases (London: Longmans, Green, 1966).