Books

A New Model For Health And Disease – Page 35

It appears that for the last forty years intelligent scientists have wasted precious effort and millions of dollars in the elusive quest for a "panacea" for the diseases of humanity. One medicine for every disease was not good enough, but one medicine to cure all diseases was the "quixotic" dream of every scientist—a dream originating from a wrong perception of who the diseased individual really was.
"Our problems in infectious diseases get bigger, more expen¬sive, and more hazardous. We are at the point where thoughtful observers are questioning not whether we are in the post-infectious era, but whether, on balance, society is much better off than we were 40 years ago, despite our hundreds of new antibiotics, hundreds of millions of prescriptions, and billions of dollars of expense. In view of all the evidence, a positive answer to this question can no longer be given with confidence; it is a legitimate question….
"It appears that we could double or halve our total health expenditures without significantly affecting the nation’s health. It seems that in the United States there is no longer any important relation between the amount of money spent on traditional health care and the results achieved."51
In spite of utter failure and frustration coming from within medical ranks, the "quest" is still obstinately pursued, without a change in the way of thinking, without anybody seriously challenging the principles underlying current research meth¬ods.
On the contrary, some medical authorities still insist that the assumption is valid that general medicine is beneficial and leads to a decline in mortality rate and an increase in life expectancy. This belief, to say the least, is questionable today, and I am sure it will be invalidated in a few years’ time. As Dubos wrote in 1968, "While they have done much in the prevention and treatment of a few specific diseases, they have so far failed to increase true longevity or to create positive health."52
Simmons states, "Most of the major improvements in longev¬ity in this century, and the dramatic decrease in mortality from infectious diseases specifically, occurred long before we began our massive spending for health care and antibiotic drugs. McKinlay suggests that only about 3.5% of the fall of the overall death rate in this century can reasonably be attributed to