rather than black-and-white differences. It could be impossible to come to a decision, if based upon a written case with no underlining to convey the intensity of the symptoms as described by the patient. Homeopathy is a science based upon finely tuned shades of differences from one remedy to another. This fact is perhaps nowhere so evident as in the comparison of Chelidonium and Lyc..
Other Mental symptoms
Ill-humour and irritability are repeatedly documented features of Chelidonium. For instance: ‘Fretful mood, with a tendency to weep.’ Vexed about every trifle, with violent attacks of anger and rage. Inclined to anger, to temper tantrums. Very irritable and ill- humoured. From the provings: ‘Very irritable mood since eight days. Every day temper tantrum without any provocation. She wants to beat her children and trembles with rage because she has no reason to do it.’ (Repertory rubric ‘Children, wants to beat her: Chelidonium’, only remedy, comes from this description.)
The sluggishness of the intellect may extend to the whole organism. Unconquerable aversion to motion and exercise. ‘A kind of horror of movement … excessive and continued apathy, with aversion to exercise, spirits remaining unaltered’ (Teste). Feels tired and prostrated from the least exertion. ‘Great sluggishness and sleepiness; feels prostrated, weary, sick; weary, listless, no desire for anything; weariness and sluggishness of limbs.’ A vague feeling of discomfort as if sick. ‘Great discomfort, feels very unwell without knowing what is the matter; has to lie down without being able to sleep, everything is annoying and intolerable’ (Hahnemann). Great desire to lie down, even without sleepiness. Great sleepiness throughout the day.
The delirious states of Chelidonium also tend to be passive, lethargic, quiet, and are followed by great lethargy and sleepiness. ‘Quiet delirium, mostly at night; later sopor also by day’ (Buchmann).