Books

Essence of Materia Medica – page 67

sive (in a chronic case). Aside from the slowness of response, Chel¬idonium patients are unlikely to report improvement anyway. They are never satisfied until they see tangible, objective, incon-trovertible results. Even if the remedy were to produce a mirac-ulous change, such a patient will not admit it until a year_pr so of relief has passed. Even then he may be suspicious. He will say, "You say I am better, but the other doctors all said my liver will never be normal again. How can what you say be possible?" He may even insist on getting liver function tests in the hope that one of them will prove to you that the liver is still affected —all this in spite of relief.
Of course, differentiation between Lycopodium and Chelidonium can be quite a problem in a particular case. Generally, Cheli¬donium is much more forceful and heedless of risks in expres¬sing his domineering opinions; Lycopodium is more timid and cowardly, limiting his domination to subordinates. Both have an anxiety about health, it is less intense and more realistic and matter of fact in Chelidonium. Both remedies are right-sided but Chelidonium’s pain more characteristically radiates to the infer¬ior angle of the scapula. Lycopodium tends to lie on its right side, whereas Chelidonium is not ameliorated in this position and will tend to lie on the left side. Both have bloatedness and disten¬sion but Chelidonium not nearly as intensely as Lycopodium. Lycopodium has much stronger desire for sweets than Cheli¬donium. Lycopodium usually is neutral about cheese, whereas Chelidonium either has a strong desire for or strong aversion to cheese. Both desire warm drinks and warm food and are ame¬liorated by them. Both do not feel well on waking, but Cheli¬donium has a specific aggravation at 4 a.m. Chelidonium does not share Lycopodium’s specific 4 p.m. aggravation, but both remedies are ameliorated in the evening.
The differentiation between Chelidonium and Lycopodium is a perfect example of the necessity for underlining in recording cases. The differentiation is based mostly on shades of intensity, rather than black and white differences. It could be impossible to decide based upon a written case with no underlining to convey the intensity of the symptoms as described by the patient. Homoe¬opathy is a science based upon finely tuned shades of differen¬ces from one remedy another to. Perhaps nowhere else is this fact so evident as in comparing Chelidonium and Lycopodium.