Books

Essence of Materia Medica – page 115

consider Kali iodatum, Kali bichromicum, Arsenicum, or Allium cepa. However, the marked aggravation from lying down, and amel-ioration from being up and about, will lead you to Mag.mur. The patient may have a nasal catarrh which is tolerable under ordi-nary circumstances, but the moment he lies down and closes his eyes he starts coughing and choking severely. He is forced to get up, and then he is immediately relieved. This is exactly the opposite of Manganum, which is markedly relieved by lying down.
Another primary characteristic of Mag. mur. is the aggravation from salt. This probably explains why Mag. mur. is aggravated by swimming in the sea. The salt element has an adverse effect on the metabolism of these patients in general. After swimming in the sea, they not only feel worse in their local symptoms, but they feel completely drained of energy in general.
Mag. mur. is intolerant to cold in general. In spite of this, they may have warm feet—even to the extent of sticking them out of the covers. It belongs to a small group of remedies which are chilly but which also stick their feet out; Chamomilla, Phosphorus, Sanicula (Medorrhinum also sticks its feet out but is not so chilly).
Mag. mur. is chilly but also feels better in open air. It is also better from motion. Like Rhus tox., Mag.mur. patients will bundle up well and go out for a walk in the open air. This can be difficult to differentiate from Rhus tox. in some cases. The nature of the morning aggravation can be a keypoint, as mentioned. It would be very rare to find a Mag.mur. patient who is not aggravated in his whole being in the morning. Also, Rhus tox. has a strong desire for milk. Mag.mur. may have a desire for milk as well, but it is strongly aggravated by it. Milk causes a general aggra-vation and also a diarrhoea—mushy, unformed stools.
Mag.mur. patients often have a desire for sweets, and also for fruits and they have a strong desire for vegetables. Mag. carb., by contrast has an aversion to vegetables, especially to artichokes.
A few more symptoms which stand out in my experience; Mag.mur. prefers to sleep on the left side, and it is aggravated by lying on the right side. There are severe jerkings or electric-like sensations—especially when lying down. All magnesias are very sensitive to slight touch; Mag.mur. and Mag.phos. in par-ticular are also better from hard pressure. There may be numb-