Books

The Celle Seminars_Page 83

Celle Seminar I, Case 2: Insanity

to insanity. What is the remedy? You’ll find in the Synthetic Repertory that the remedy is Staphisagria. However, perhaps Staphisagria should be in the general rubric. Staphisagria has acute insanity, but this isn’t really the most pressing problem here. The symptomatology points toward insanity, but it is not real insanity. You see in the course of interviewing the patient that she becomes more and more precise, her answers more and more clear. The patient isn’t really a confused person at all; she knows what she’s about. She is merely a very sensitive person. Staphisagria patients are sensitive people who tend to escape easily into an emotional outlet that imitates insanity. Were this a case of real psychosis, then we would have a harder time handling her because we, as homeopaths, do not have a classic definition of insanity at our disposal. Real insanity is very difficult to cure and treatment usually extends over a long period of time. But we can help her because we are not dealing with a real psychosis here. This patient only imitates insanity during an acute emotional crisis. Here the problem is really the patient’s marital relationship. If you give her Staphisagria, the patient will most probably begin to defend herself against the injustices she’s had to accept in her marriage. Still, the problems she has suppressed will not be solved that quickly. You may have to see the patient several times and administer repeated doses of Staphisagria before she will be in a condition to make a concrete decision about her life, to leave her husband or to stay.
(A.2): Why didn’t you consider Pulsatilla? I thought of Pulsatilla, but now, in light of this analysis, I have problems differentiating between Pulsatilla and Staphisagria. Could you say something about this?
(G.V.): I did not consider Pulsatilla because we heard at the beginning of the interview: »While abroad a year later she was afraid that she would not be equal to her tasks, so she again faked unconsciousness. At that time she was diagnosed as having epilepsy, she suffered a nervous breakdown, and was most probably treated with electroshock therapy. Hallucinations about God and her lost virginity." Consider the expression, »God and

83