Books

The Celle Seminars_Page 475

Celle Seminar I, Case 18: Epilepsy

be this type of person, he just seemed very childish. He also had characteristics of Cicuta, which is a remedy primarily given for epilepsy.
(A. 16): I don’t know why we have to repertorize the symptoms of the attack either with the Expert System or with flat rep-ertorization.
(G.V.): Well, grand mal seizures do not always have these features of shrieking before the attack and this deep cry. Such symptoms are not always present. Even urination and biting the tongue are not always there. These are common symptoms of the remedy, but if you choose this remedy because of these features alone, you will be wrong. Of course, a lot of remedies have these features, but you have to take into consideration all the other features you see during an interrogation. Now, you have to go completely away from the idea of epilepsy in doing your reper-torization; that means that you have to exclude the epileptic symptomatology in order to see what other remedies may be coming through. It is a fact that we can connect certain pathology to a certain type and then use this together with all the other repertorization. Actually, when you look at such a case, you will tend to look at remedies which can produce similar states.
(A.17): I think there is some violence in his actions: his wife said that he gets violent when they are discussing. Where is this special element of violence in Cicuta? It is also in Bufo. And the other point is his brain injury: I think Bufo is also one of the remedies that may follow an injury to the brain. It is not in Kent, but I think it is nevertheless a fact. The other thing is the masturbation; I don’t think you could see what it was about. Perhaps his wife goes out and leaves him at home and he’s lonely.
(G.V.): Well, still, you have not persuaded me. I would choose Bufo as a third possibility, using first Cicuta, then Arnica, and then Bufo. Of course, no case is very clear, and this one is especially difficult. It’s hard to say for sure what the best remedy would be. All I can do is try my best.

475