Books

The Celle Seminars_Page 433

Celle Seminar I, Case 16: Rheumatoid Arthritis

(G.V.): Yes. If it weren’t such a difficult problem, we would have decided that Medorrhinum was the remedy.
(A.27): I think that when we look at this grief, which happened last year, then we have to consider what changed after the delivery. She lost several things after the delivery: her aversion to milk changed into a desire for milk, she had this special grief, and she had involuntary urination when she laughed and coughed. All these are Natrum symptoms. But when we consider it on the mental level, she also has Phosphorus symptoms, for example, these fears we’ve talked about. When we combine these two we get Natrum phosphoricum, which especially has a shortening of the knee joints. Therefore, I think that the remedy could be Natrum phosphoricum.
(A.28): When her friend came onto the scene, one of the first things he mentioned when describing her was that she sticks to minor things; she has many ideas, but she has difficulties with minor problems. I’ve had difficulty finding the right rubric for that in Kent. But now I’ve found here under impatient about trifles, that Medorrhinum is in the second degree. So, I would also give Medorrhinum now.
(A.29): Sulphur and Natrum muriaticum art both in the first degree.
(G.V.): How did the boyfriend describe her? As a person who takes the initiative, has a lot of ideas—perhaps too many ideas— and she cannot carry them all out all by herself, so of course she needs his help. She is a person who fights, who is quite tough; she is not a soft person. All this seems to be clear Phosphorus symptomatology.
(A.30): Phosphorus is not only soft and weak, it also has this element of fighting.
(G.V.): Yes. If this were the first thing her boyfriend had said, you would tend to think more of Lilium tigrinum than Phosphorus. He softened up when I insisted, he modified his statement and said that she does not really fight and shout, although she is definitely not a soft character; she has her moments of aggression. There was definitely an imprint of grief upon her because

433