Books

The Celle Seminars_Page 401

Celle Seminar I, Case 15: Forgetfulness/Depression

When I first started going to America I was confronted with this problem. I found that, although I gave a remedy after a good analysis, sometimes there was no effect. 10M, 50M, no effect. This case here is a case of Nitricum acidum, and I know this like I know that the other one was a case of Medorrhinum. So, what should I do if the remedy does not act? What happens then? Let’s say that I give Medorrhinum 10M and nothing happens. You could wind up losing six months just by waiting for results. Sup¬pose I then say, »Okay, give a 200«, and it acts beautifully, what has happened then? Where was the action of the 10M?
I had a case in London two years ago for which I prescribed a very strange and rarely used remedy: Paris quadrifolia. The patient came back after three months and said, »Fm the same. There is no change at all.« I took into consideration all the symptoms and saw that there was indeed no change. I went to the classes, like our group here, and I asked what we should do. Everybody said, »Wrong remedy!« But for me the remedy was still Paris. Someone asked me where I’d bought the remedy. I mentioned a pharmacy and was then advised to go to all the other pharmacies, buy Paris 30, and use those potencies, because at least one of them would be correct. The case developed fantastically! Eventually the patient reported a breaking out of a tumor, a beautiful reaction. How can I now rely on 10M alone?
I’ve had similar problems in America several times. Take for instance an experience I had during one of my classes. There was a doctor attending my talk, and I saw that he was about to faint. I stopped the class and said, »Go upstairs and lie down. What are your symptoms ?« After hearing them I said, »Carbo vegetabilis, give him a dose of Car bo vegetabilis 1M,« and then I went back to the class. The patient was vomiting and had diarrhea, which he’d had since the day before. By the time I saw him, he was completely exhausted and on the verge of fainting. When I finished the class, I went upstairs and asked how he was doing. »I’m the same,« he answered. Then he said, »I don’t think the remedy is Carbo vegetabilis, but rather Arsenicum, because I’m beginning to be afraid that I’ll die.« It is very difficult to differentiate be-

401