Books

The Celle Seminars_Page 312

George Vithoulkas

(A.4): Not all of the Magnesias support the sort of disharmony she relates in her life, for instance, in her family. Instead of anger being released, they show muscular or nervous pains, for example, on the right side with Magnesia tnuriatica. The remedy could be Magnesia tnuriatica because she is better at the seaside and when she’s swimming. But it could also be Magnesia sulphurica, because if you look on page 419 in Boericke, you’ll see bruised and ulcerative pain between the shoulders, which would account for why she can’t lie on her back. The left arm and foot fall asleep in bed, in the morning after waking, and you have crawling in the tips of the fingers of the left hand, better on rubbing. That’s all.
(G.V.): Why Stapbisagria?
(A. 10): I found it difficult to decide whether she is open or closed; in any case, she is a very nice person. I feel that for her, her life history is a question of depression or suppression or compression of feelings. I think it started with her family. During the first four months of her marriage she was able to struggle, but then she gave up again and the feelings of being depressed returned.
(G.V.): Medorrbinum?
(A.5): This person seems to me to be very sensitive. She has fitful energy states that go up and down; desires salt and sweets; better by the ocean; high sexual energy; desire for sour fruit, even though she has a sensitive tongue, and sensitivity to cold.
(G.V.): Well, here you are, take your choice. What should we do? Let me ask you a question first before we go any further. In relating her case, which remedies did she say definitely helped? Ignatia and Natrum muriaticum. That means that this person experienced grief at a certain period in her life, which was taken away, to some extent, by Ignatia and Natrum muriaticum. The question we should be asking now is whether this person is constitutionally Natrum muriaticum or Ignatia. However, she has related certain things that completely lead us away from these two remedies. To find out whether she is really Natrum muriaticum or Ignatia, I go back a little bit in her history and consider

312