Books

The Science of Homeopathy – page 156

ization of the preparations.

Of course, the practice of some unscrupulous pharmacies to succuss only after every 5 or 10 dilutions must be deplored and rejected. In ad- dition, the modern tendency to develop machines which apply kinetic energy in unconventional ways (i.e., by ultrasound, by shooting a jet of solvent into a swirling vat, etc.) must be rejected. In a purely physical sense, such deviations might be effective, but the vast body of homeo- pathic experience has thus far been built upon medicines prepared by the standard method described above; therefore, major alterations in- troduce serious uncertainties into interpretation of results. Any chang- es in technique must be tested experimentally very thoroughly over a long period of time to confirm their validity. Conscientious practitio- ners must take the responsibility to determine the specific methods used in preparing their remedies and only purchase medicines from those pharmacies maintaining the highest of classical standards.

At present, there are two equally valid methods of preparing dilu- tion. The Hahnemannian method takes one drop of the previous po- tency diluted into alcohol, succusses, and then discards the glass vial after preparing each potency. The Korsakoff method pours out the solvent from the previous potency, leaving a drop on the walls of the vial (which has been determined to be a consistent size each time), and then adds the new solvent for the next potency; thus, by the Korsakoff method the same vial is used for each potency. Of course, even in the korsakoff method, it is desirable from time to time to set aside inter- mediate potencies for storage, so the total number of vials used for, say, a 200 potency might be 6 or 8, whereas by the Hahnemannian method 200 vials would be required.

The difference between Hahnemannian and Korsakoff preparations has sparked considerable controversy among homeopaths. The argu- ment against the Korsakoff method is that it might result in a mixture of potencies from one level to another. To me, this argument doesn’t make sense. After all, when the dilution is made and the vial suc- cussed, the entire solution and vial have been raised to a new ampli- tude of vibration. How can any one portion of the solution avoid under- going the same change as all other portions? Therefore, there cannot be “contamination” from one potency to another.

This is not a merely academic distinction. It has tremendous practi- cal importance to homeopathic pharmacists. To perform the Hahn- emannian method, a very large number of vials must be used, and old vials can be re-used only by heating in an oven to very high tempera- tures. Such a procedure is very expensive, of course, and unnecessary. In order to help preserve our pharmacies, and their standards, the Kor-