Books

The Celle Seminars_Page 273

Celle Seminar I, Case 9: Lymphoma

also Pulsatilla, but then too many elements made me unhappy about the idea of Pulsatilla. I think Carcinosinum is so close to Pulsatilla that it fits this case very well.
(G.V.): You say that it is close to many remedies, so obviously we do not have a clear Carcinosinum picture. I don’t know if you have specific information about Carcinosinum, but I know that I certainly don’t have a clear picture of it; you could fit it into anything. Once you see a tendency towards cancer in a family, you can always use Carcinosinum and it will sometimes bring forth a reaction. But I cannot say that I would prescribe Carcinosinum in this case based on the symptomatology alone, at least not as a first remedy.
(A.22): I also thought of Phosphorus because of the mental symptoms, the openness with which she presented herself in the interview, fear of darkness and heights, and coldness and thirst.
(G.V.): I also thought of Phosphorus. I even asked some questions in that direction. There were some problems with Phosphorus though because she did not appear to have any kind of strong hemorrhages and also, if you remember, she did not like cold drinks. On the contrary, she liked things lukewarm, which is a symptom that will lead you away from Phosphorus.
(A.23): What is your argument against Silicea? It is also con
sidered a cold Pulsatilla.
(G.V.): Yes, we spoke about whether it would come first or second as a remedy. One way to look at the case is to say, if we prescribe Pulsatilla first, most probably Silicea will follow. You see, I have been thinking like everybody else, and I have tried to sort out all the information. We have some very prominent information: worse in cold, which led you to consider certain Silicea symptoms. But I would like to see a more solid confirmation of this remedy. Silicea is not only coldness, but more strongly, breaking of nails. But she says that although she has soft nails, they don’t break. When I asked her questions leading towards Silicea, for example, whether she could appear in front of a group given that she is a timid person, I would not have expected the kind of fears she mentioned. The most I would have expected

273