Books

THE BERN SEMINAR-PAGE 102

changed houses. Why do I know that? Because I asked her when John stopped eating fruit, and aversion to fruit is a keynote for Ignatia. You will see me ask her when John stopped eating fruit, and her answer will be: from the day we changed houses. I will then ask: »When did you change houses,« and she will reply: »When we divorced I took John to another house.« She does not connect these things with one another. She does not know what I am trying to get at, but she is giving perfect answers: »When was that?« »A year and a half ago,« that means that a year and an half ago John went into an Ignatia state. He lived in an Ignatia state with shifting, changing moods; sometimes he is elated, sometimes he is depressed. When his mother makes the decision to leave John and go to work, John gets the big blow and his health declines. No remedy other than Ignatia will do anything for that child, it is too obvious that this is the correct remedy. Now open your books to chorea, »chorea: better lying,« which remedies are indicated there? There are two remedies: Ignatia and Cuprum. Which is in italics? (A.): Both.
(G.V.): Which one would you choose if you don’t see this? Cuprum. If you, as the practitioner, had seen this, you would have chosen Cuprum because you overlooked something very important. (A.): There is also »chorea after grief« which is only Ignatia. (G.V.): Very good, I did not know that. I told you I had no idea, I just went right through to the heart of the matter by observing what was happening. You have to observe, that is why I say please observe, don’t rely on what the mother says. If you stop the inquisition at the point where his mother says: »We have been talking about the new house, and John has overheard this,« you’ll miss the correct remedy. »Talking about the new house,« what does this really mean?
VIDEO
(G.V.): Did you discuss this with John?
(Mother): I told him, but he did not say much about it, you know.
LIVE
(G.V.): He did not say much about it. Of course he did not say much about it! Again, this is the idea of a silent grief. Do you see how clear the remedy is? I know it because I’ve also been listening to what is not being said.